Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Florent Beuyet's avatar

The 'a coinflip is 50%' line is the one I'd put on a poster. Eighty percent agreement sounds reassuring until you ask what the agreement would be if the literature were guessing — and in nutrition, where the same exposure gets both answers, that's not a hypothetical.

Where I land, from behind a pharmacy counter, is on triangulation — with a wrinkle. A patient brings me the coffee headline and asks whether to drink more of it. The answer isn't 'the evidence is weak'; it's that one cup holds hundreds of compounds pulling in different directions, at doses nothing like the concentrated extracts in the lab work. Drug development demands the randomized step before exposing millions; nutrition never gets one, so the 'totality' stays provisional forever.

Your pretest probability point is the one that sticks. After hundreds of billions spent on dementia, the prior that a pantry staple succeeds where purpose-built molecules failed should be vanishingly small. Skepticism can go too far — but at the counter, the cost of under-skepticism is a patient rearranging their life around a hazard ratio.

Ready for more?