Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hansang Bae's avatar

RE: "Young people who want to do good. Sadly, they are typically so poorly trained in critical thinking"

This, apparently, has always been the case. Gov Reagan when talking to the Berkeley staff during the 1969 riots said about the students protesting and damaging campus (a verbatim quote) "All of it began when some of you who know better and old enough to know better let young people think that they have the right to choose the laws that they would obey as long as they were doing it in the name of social justice"

As the old saying goes, if you're not a liberal in your twenties, you don't have a heart. But if you're not a conservative in your forties, you don't have a brain.

Expand full comment
Woot's avatar

While I appreciate the open discussion on this Stack and others it is a little disheartening to see such blindness even in people that seem open to discussion. Dr. Prasad mentions a post on this Stack from one of his colleagues that makes the statement “I… know that the initial series saved millions of lives.”. As proof of this point he provides a link to a blog post about a modeling exercise. It is no surprise that a model developed by conflicted organization ("Commonwealth Fund") that has a base assumption that the vaccine is effective produces results that show the vaccine is effective. This is not science and is an illustration of the just the type of dangerous conclusions from “bad” science that Dr. Prasad mentions in his post.

About the Commonwealth Fund. “In addition to producing research supporting greater government control of the hospital and health insurance systems, the Commonwealth Fund convened the Commonwealth Fund Commission on a National Public Health System to promote increased federal control of public health after the COVID-19 pandemic”

Expand full comment
55 more comments...

No posts