46 Comments
User's avatar
Chris Fehr's avatar

"Would you advise a pregnant woman to limit the use of medications unless absolutely necessary?"

Wouldn't that be good advice for anyone and any medication? They can do great good but that doesn't mean taking more of a good thing is even better.

Dr. Ashori MD's avatar

Interesting read. I would say that Dr. Prasad covers these questions with so much detail and nuance that the answers given here are almost the opposite of what I've heard. It would be great for medicine to be a simple FAQ but I'm not sure if lends itself well to that. There's nothing wrong with nuance or a deeper dive.

Raj Batra's avatar

Nice summation of contemporary queries with reasoned opinions….

A question I have asked myself and never answered satisfactorily is

“when does an academic physician going through the ladder ranks of professional/professorial series actually graduate?”

This is a question that’s rooted in intrinsic versus extrinsic value is one’s work and worth. Does it have an answer?

Amethyst's avatar

SSRIs are overused. Absolutely. But it's not the only psychiatric drug that is overused.

Benzodiazepines. Despite all the risks that they involve.

Seroquel for the elderly. With their increased risks of falls that most describers don't want to acknowledge.

MSB's avatar

Your comment on China didn't sound 100% accurate, so I looked it up. China legally requires written Informed Consent Forms and institutional ethical review before enrolling human subjects into biotech, clinical, or medical research studies.

Ben T's avatar

Sure, but do they follow or enforce that, considering all the human rights violations in China?

MSB's avatar

Oh, this is so wonderful for American taxpayers. The US spends millions of $ every year on anti-China propaganda, and it's working!

tracy's avatar

But to be fair, hasn't the Big Pharma bias usually been right-wing (and by right-wing I mean capitalism and profits before everything else).

The Left used to be anti-Big Pharma.

MZap's avatar

mRNA mumps is already on the way

MHYDE's avatar

The obvious corollary to the first question is: what was the point (and what are the potential harms) of Trump's executive order pertaining to splitting up the MMR? I think Vinay is correct that it will never happen, so what is the outcome of the president's order? It seems the most likely effect is that people will simply avoid the MMR and wait for an alternative that doesn't and will never exist. What a tremendously harmful and stupid decision.

toolate's avatar

Is the absence of evidence evidence of absence??

Tim Van Geem's avatar

I would love to hear Vinay and this cohorts comment on the medical sensibilities of the " medical emergency kit" sold via The Wellness Co. These kits contain Ivermectin; amoxicillin and azithromycin for persons to self diagnose and self-treat based on their symptoms . This approach to self-medical care is patently dangerous, misleading, and has the potential to create antibiotic resistance . The insinuation that parasitic infections are so common in people to justify the treatment with Ivermectin is ludicrous and unwarranted . Just because you do not feel good for any reason, " you probably have a parasitic infection" ? !. If people are self-medicating with an antibiotic that is ineffective for their given condition they may wait too long for real medical intervention falsely thinking that their "kit" Rx will treat it , potentially creating a life-threatening scenario like pneumonia, or antibiotic-resistant infection, unrealized viral infection; lymphoma; etc etc etc.( DrTim (parasitologist and veterinarian. )

Jim Ryser's avatar

I don’t know if it makes me smarter or crazier that I agree with your responses. But it’s nice to know I’m not alone either way.

PharmHand's avatar

Having significant knowledge and understanding of about 90% of the various questions and answers presented here, I agree with Dr Prasad on all his answers regarding those 90%. Having listened to the Reason interview with Nick Gillespie I come away very positively impressed with both men. Great job…!

Chad Raymond's avatar

Why are so many physicians so reluctant to deprescribe a patient's meds despite little to no evidence that the meds are having a beneficial treatment effect on that individual?

Christopher Johnson's avatar

Mostly clinical inertia.

If everything is going fine, no reason to change.

If the patient complains of a problem, sure we can stop that medication

Amethyst's avatar

I heard various replies to this one. Among them:

We are doctors, we have to do something, so we prescribe.

There's no side effects of that medication.

I will never forget an intern who deprescribed drugs to a patient saying "who am I treating, myself or the patient?"

Brenda Becker's avatar

Your dismissal of the oncologist's role under AI seems glib. Oncos already consult the literature based on patient scans and test results. If this is done via AI, who replaces the onco for actual patient care and follow-up, their overworked PCP?

brianne fitzgerald's avatar

Straight to the point and no well maybe. I am a fangirl of Vinay P

MSB's avatar

I am too, though I don't always agree with his views. But I always defend him online because of his integrity. I myself studied some of his videos when helping a friend's relative navigate some cancer choices. I know someone who bought his book (Malignant) years ago for similar reasons, when they were helping someone navigate a cancer crisis. It's sad he was ousted from the USFDA, but it did prove his incorruptibility. Let me not forget to mention his great sense of humour.

Jenni Rubatt's avatar

Medicare for all not decreasing deaths? I can see that. Do you think it would decrease health care spending?

Ben T's avatar

I think he is kind of on record saying it would increase spending... Basically the problem is if we cover everybody with Medicare, but continue to have Medicare pay for treatments that don't work, then those treatments just continue to get paid for more and more.