Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Adam Cifu, MD's avatar

Great work Paul. I love the line "Outlive is definitely a book about primary care written by a surgeon."

Expand full comment
jody's avatar

Great article about various approaches in medicine. I ended up in the overdiagnosis category about five years ago. Because of lingering back pain I was given an MRI. a few days later I was told that I needed to see an endocrinologist because something bad showed up in my thyroid. They were supposed to be looking at my lower back but I guess at Kaiser they look at everything from your neck to your sacrum.

The visit to the endocrinologist contained about 30 needle pokes into my throat to determine what kind of lesions were on my thyroid.

By the following week they had me scheduled to speak with the head and neck cancer surgeon because I probably had thyroid cancer.

I was about to start work in the national tour of (wicked) and I was trying to imagine when I would get my thyroid removed and when I would then begin rehearsal.

Thank God for the Internet. I started doing a Google search on everything they had described to me and found the doctor at Sloan Kettering in New York City who studied thyroid cancers and spoke about the option of ‘active surveillance’.

He wrote about the fact that many of these small papillary thyroid cancers never grow and that active surveillance is a good option for many people.

The next time I spoke with the doctors at Kaiser I explained that I was not going to have my thyroid removed and that I was going to find a doctor that had an active surveillance study.

Sloan Kettering recommended a doctor down at Cedars Sinai in Los Angeles and for the past five years I go down there every year and with ultrasound they determine that it is not growing and I am relieved and grateful that I did my research and have kept my thyroid.

Apparently there is a massive amount of overdiagnosis with these kinds of thyroid lesions.

Thank you for your article.

Expand full comment
87 more comments...

No posts