Discussion about this post

User's avatar
DM, MD's avatar

Well as a physician I have appreciated this EBM policy, but as a patient I found it unbearably cruel. I have Stage IVB ovarian ca, and after a massive debulking surgery including TAH, omentectomy, cholecystectomy, appendectomy, partial hepatectomy, partial diaphragmatic resection I was left, as a 68 year old, with a HB of 7 and was never transfused except for 1 unit intra-op. This required 10 days of post-op care then discharge. I was weaker than a sick kitten, could barely stand up, was short of breath with minimal exertion. Yes I slowly came up on my own in the months that followed. I don't expect anecdote to change anything but we should think long and hard on the impact of this on patients. Outcome may be the same but quality of life surely is not.

Expand full comment
KC's avatar

I hemorrhaged after the birth of my first child and the doctor didn’t feel like I needed a transfusion even though my HB had dropped down to 5. He reasoned I was in my mid twenties and would bounce back and it wasn’t worth the potential side effects of receiving blood. I was young and trusted him. Recovery was awful: my hair and nails stopped growing, I stopped sweating, my heart raced for weeks. I was incredibly weak. It took me 6 months to get back to not needing a nap every day (luckily it was my first kid, she was a good sleeper, and I was able to stay home with her and nap when she napped) and over a year before I felt “normal”, though it was another few years before my hb was high enough to give blood again. And then when I did finally donate again it knocked me out for several weeks, so I haven’t tried to donate for over 20 years now. I just don’t want to risk the fatigue.

Over the years I’ve had other friends lose blood during birth and they were all given blood to recover and none of their HB numbers were below 8. They were able to bounce back rapidly. From my experience and watching my friends’ experiences I’d come to the conclusion my original doctor was a quack and a more liberal blood transfusion policy was a good thing. This article was rather depressing that in that all they’re measuring to test success is morality. There’s so much more to receiving blood than not dying.

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts