Dedicated, personalized patient care; inquiry aimed at improving medical practice; training the next generation so that medicine will continue to improve.
I so appreciate your thoughts and expressing the human side of Medical care. I'm a nurse and what AI is unable to do is recognize any of the nuances detected only by observation and conversation. For example, you can be speaking to a patient and while they're saying they have no pain you observe facial grimacing the entire time. What's also very disturbing is nurses are not privy to exactly what AI is doing; meaning when and where it has been incorporated into all the systems we use from records to IV pumps. In fact, I only learned the extent it was being used in doctors notes, discharge summaries, etc. from sensible medicine and then my own research. It's no wonder 2/3 of after visit summaries I've read while seeking a surgeon for a hamstring Avulsion do not reflect anything discussed during the visit or is completely inaccurate which then requires me jumping through hoops to correct the information. More importantly is several showed no interest in how I'd prefer to treat it.
Another example.
My 91 year old mom was recently discharged for treating bacteremia. Discharged yesterday so I was reviewing the discharge instructions with her today. She told me they stopped one of her anti- hypertensive meds and in addition to the oral antibiotic they Rxd her Clonidine .1mg q 8 hours for SBP > 150mm Hg.
This is an example of the attending not giving a shit about the person. Of course I said -Do not take it. Go back on what you were on, keep a log of BP readings a few days and discuss at your appt with your primary doctor next week.
If I weren't a nurse or if I hadn't called from a different state she would quite easily been
Well, so what we get out of AI is that we should just go back to writing the notes that drove all of medical practice for decades -- what the doctor is thinking and why. Used to be one could competently care for a patient by reading the most recent few doctor notes (and perhaps a consultant note or two). Now, forty years later, we have discovered that that is far more useful than the endless slop that comprises all 100 Epic tabs through which we are supposed to slog.
Some of us have been pointing this out for decades. This is not something magic we get from AI. It was always the right thing to be doing. Why we have tolerated the EMRs and administrivia that non-practitioners thought would be good for us or for patients is the part that eludes me.
The suggestion that resonated with me the most was “document your thinking”.
I can’t remember the last time I saw an inpatient note - even by consultants- that didn’t consist only of a recitation of the history, a listing of (all) the labs, and a plan.
No thinking interposed between the data and the plan at all. Interpreting the labs, discussing the differential diagnosis, even simply comparing how the patient is today compare with yesterday would be so helpful. It’s the thinking that distinguishes physicians from protocol-driven support staff.
I have to look at it like I do my passion outside of my passion for helping those with chronic pain and/or addiction…hunting! If I use modern tools to increase my ability to be humane, to save (dare I say dangerous) work on my back and body, and improve my woodsmanship skills (and most importantly ENJOYMENT!), then we compare: stick and string bow to compound (for me both more accurate and humane), dragging to using a UTV (saves my back), winches on my Polaris vs lifting (see prior), which gives me time to practice the art of accurate shooting (keeps me strong), more time scouting (keeps woodsmanship sharp and keeps legs exercised), and then enjoying the entirety of the experience! In the end, a perfectly cooked blackstrap tastes the same - and even better because I’m not in the hospital recovering from a strain first…but using all the modern gear was used to make me, the hunter, more efficient. And if we can both enjoy and be efficient at the necessary human parts of our jobs, using the helpers of AI will be good. Yes, it’s deer season here in the Midwest. Loading up the UTV now…
Thanks, Adam! This describes much of emergency medicine. Personally, I don’t find integrated AI useful yet. The first order of business- EHR integration across the country- is still missing. Sure “EPIC everywhere” is an improvement but when the “everywhere” doesn’t include the hospital down the road that patients bounce between, AI can’t solve access to full patient information.
Also, #8- remind physicians that they need to get paid for training LLMs.
And when The Pulse hits, our value goes up ! We continue dehumanizing humanity. We are doing more, but, are we achieving relevant outcomes? Instead of mandatory corporate compliance courses, why not review how to pick up a phone and arrange for a consult or call in a critical prescription? Go to the radiologist office and review images in person? Review how to change a flat tire. Table manners. Genuine respect and civility. True teamwork instead of the “ come and get it “ mentality, if you know someone else needs it now, don’t just report it and contact the person directly. Review and update drug interactions and notify on the clinically relevant ones. Same with lab panic values. Way too much background noise. But, the patient died in electrolyte balance.
Regarding #3 - document your thinking. Amen! May we let the medical record serve again as an effective means of communication - both to our future selves, and to our colleagues. If you are talking to my 82-year-old patient about whether or not to go forward with a TAVR, if you are giving my patient a choice between BCG treatment in the bladder vs cystectomy, if you don't think this patient needs to get a coronary angiogram, if you are concerned that the redo hernia repair is going to be complicated due to the mesh.... let me know your thoughts! In your words! I don't need the pages of CYA/billing boilerplate (include at the bottom if you must), I need the thinking behind the decision. That way I can have confidence in (or question) the plan and help counsel the patient on their next course of action.
Good article - I like the positive spin. My only concern would be AI calling with test results. As a nurse in a Free Clinic, many times when I call patients with their results, they have other unrelated questions or ask questions about making an appointment, etc.
As a patient, I hate talking to AI. I'd rather a message in the portal/email - if that comes from AI, I am fine with that.
I would also add, if you have the time, and if you don’t make it to ask the patient who they are. A patient I’d seen for years came in wearing his World War II hat. I sat down that day and asked him to explain and heard about the 29th infantry that landed in D-Day + 3. First unit into Berlin, sometimes only going 50 yards in a day. Survives that nightmare and they put them on a ship eventually, where they’re quarantined in New Jersey because they have too much PTSD, I assume, to be out in public for three months. Gets drafted again for Korea, and when they see that he was infantry in World War II, make him a cook in the Navy. At 93, we put a couple stents in the circumflex and his main problem was his prostate. Next guy was 90 very hearing impaired , and when I asked what he did, he yelled out “secret service” . His wife confirmed it, and he showed me his Timex, a Timex, no joke, that had an inscription on the back that says to so-and-so from “LBJ”. Point is the joy and the privilege of medicine is getting to know people as people, and we haven’t been able to because we’ve been buried doing other ridiculous things. If AI does give time back and we use it not to see even more patients in the day and get back to the same craziness, please use it and teach, use it and teach the younger doctors to use it to really understand who they are treating. I promise it will increase the joy and job satisfaction that they have and improve patient care. You might actually get some answers you don’t expect!
Good post. Love AI subscribe by Oracle. But as a woman find number 2 on your list mildly irritating and maybe number one. Like most female positions I spend more time in the EHR than male mds do and because I’m a woman and I have to appear more empathetic than a male md, patients are willing to abuse my time where they would never do that for a very busy male doctor. Doubt me, ask your female colleagues. Keep up the good work. I would tell you to get more female MDS on sensible medicine, but there is no time – we have to go home, clean the house and do all the mental preparation for everything else.
Cheer up ! The next generation is thinking differently! My junior partners are already decreasing their hours and dividing childcare responsibilities. My son who just finished his palliative fellowship has opted for a lower stress position to spend more time with his family.
I so appreciate your thoughts and expressing the human side of Medical care. I'm a nurse and what AI is unable to do is recognize any of the nuances detected only by observation and conversation. For example, you can be speaking to a patient and while they're saying they have no pain you observe facial grimacing the entire time. What's also very disturbing is nurses are not privy to exactly what AI is doing; meaning when and where it has been incorporated into all the systems we use from records to IV pumps. In fact, I only learned the extent it was being used in doctors notes, discharge summaries, etc. from sensible medicine and then my own research. It's no wonder 2/3 of after visit summaries I've read while seeking a surgeon for a hamstring Avulsion do not reflect anything discussed during the visit or is completely inaccurate which then requires me jumping through hoops to correct the information. More importantly is several showed no interest in how I'd prefer to treat it.
Another example.
My 91 year old mom was recently discharged for treating bacteremia. Discharged yesterday so I was reviewing the discharge instructions with her today. She told me they stopped one of her anti- hypertensive meds and in addition to the oral antibiotic they Rxd her Clonidine .1mg q 8 hours for SBP > 150mm Hg.
This is an example of the attending not giving a shit about the person. Of course I said -Do not take it. Go back on what you were on, keep a log of BP readings a few days and discuss at your appt with your primary doctor next week.
If I weren't a nurse or if I hadn't called from a different state she would quite easily been
Found on the floor or worse.
So thank you for being human!!
Very, very well said!!
Well, so what we get out of AI is that we should just go back to writing the notes that drove all of medical practice for decades -- what the doctor is thinking and why. Used to be one could competently care for a patient by reading the most recent few doctor notes (and perhaps a consultant note or two). Now, forty years later, we have discovered that that is far more useful than the endless slop that comprises all 100 Epic tabs through which we are supposed to slog.
Some of us have been pointing this out for decades. This is not something magic we get from AI. It was always the right thing to be doing. Why we have tolerated the EMRs and administrivia that non-practitioners thought would be good for us or for patients is the part that eludes me.
I think you got my point! 🙂
What it means to provide good medical care hasn’t changes a whole lot.
Than you.
All great suggestions.
The suggestion that resonated with me the most was “document your thinking”.
I can’t remember the last time I saw an inpatient note - even by consultants- that didn’t consist only of a recitation of the history, a listing of (all) the labs, and a plan.
No thinking interposed between the data and the plan at all. Interpreting the labs, discussing the differential diagnosis, even simply comparing how the patient is today compare with yesterday would be so helpful. It’s the thinking that distinguishes physicians from protocol-driven support staff.
Well done, sir. You've nailed exactly what AI should do: make time for people. Thank you.
I have to look at it like I do my passion outside of my passion for helping those with chronic pain and/or addiction…hunting! If I use modern tools to increase my ability to be humane, to save (dare I say dangerous) work on my back and body, and improve my woodsmanship skills (and most importantly ENJOYMENT!), then we compare: stick and string bow to compound (for me both more accurate and humane), dragging to using a UTV (saves my back), winches on my Polaris vs lifting (see prior), which gives me time to practice the art of accurate shooting (keeps me strong), more time scouting (keeps woodsmanship sharp and keeps legs exercised), and then enjoying the entirety of the experience! In the end, a perfectly cooked blackstrap tastes the same - and even better because I’m not in the hospital recovering from a strain first…but using all the modern gear was used to make me, the hunter, more efficient. And if we can both enjoy and be efficient at the necessary human parts of our jobs, using the helpers of AI will be good. Yes, it’s deer season here in the Midwest. Loading up the UTV now…
Love that analogy.
Thanks, Adam! This describes much of emergency medicine. Personally, I don’t find integrated AI useful yet. The first order of business- EHR integration across the country- is still missing. Sure “EPIC everywhere” is an improvement but when the “everywhere” doesn’t include the hospital down the road that patients bounce between, AI can’t solve access to full patient information.
Also, #8- remind physicians that they need to get paid for training LLMs.
So so true!
And when The Pulse hits, our value goes up ! We continue dehumanizing humanity. We are doing more, but, are we achieving relevant outcomes? Instead of mandatory corporate compliance courses, why not review how to pick up a phone and arrange for a consult or call in a critical prescription? Go to the radiologist office and review images in person? Review how to change a flat tire. Table manners. Genuine respect and civility. True teamwork instead of the “ come and get it “ mentality, if you know someone else needs it now, don’t just report it and contact the person directly. Review and update drug interactions and notify on the clinically relevant ones. Same with lab panic values. Way too much background noise. But, the patient died in electrolyte balance.
Agree with all Dr. Cifu!
Regarding #3 - document your thinking. Amen! May we let the medical record serve again as an effective means of communication - both to our future selves, and to our colleagues. If you are talking to my 82-year-old patient about whether or not to go forward with a TAVR, if you are giving my patient a choice between BCG treatment in the bladder vs cystectomy, if you don't think this patient needs to get a coronary angiogram, if you are concerned that the redo hernia repair is going to be complicated due to the mesh.... let me know your thoughts! In your words! I don't need the pages of CYA/billing boilerplate (include at the bottom if you must), I need the thinking behind the decision. That way I can have confidence in (or question) the plan and help counsel the patient on their next course of action.
Good article - I like the positive spin. My only concern would be AI calling with test results. As a nurse in a Free Clinic, many times when I call patients with their results, they have other unrelated questions or ask questions about making an appointment, etc.
As a patient, I hate talking to AI. I'd rather a message in the portal/email - if that comes from AI, I am fine with that.
Totally agree. I use AI to write 1st drafts of replies. If pt has further question, time to pick up the phone.
I would also add, if you have the time, and if you don’t make it to ask the patient who they are. A patient I’d seen for years came in wearing his World War II hat. I sat down that day and asked him to explain and heard about the 29th infantry that landed in D-Day + 3. First unit into Berlin, sometimes only going 50 yards in a day. Survives that nightmare and they put them on a ship eventually, where they’re quarantined in New Jersey because they have too much PTSD, I assume, to be out in public for three months. Gets drafted again for Korea, and when they see that he was infantry in World War II, make him a cook in the Navy. At 93, we put a couple stents in the circumflex and his main problem was his prostate. Next guy was 90 very hearing impaired , and when I asked what he did, he yelled out “secret service” . His wife confirmed it, and he showed me his Timex, a Timex, no joke, that had an inscription on the back that says to so-and-so from “LBJ”. Point is the joy and the privilege of medicine is getting to know people as people, and we haven’t been able to because we’ve been buried doing other ridiculous things. If AI does give time back and we use it not to see even more patients in the day and get back to the same craziness, please use it and teach, use it and teach the younger doctors to use it to really understand who they are treating. I promise it will increase the joy and job satisfaction that they have and improve patient care. You might actually get some answers you don’t expect!
The day AI asks “ how’s yo’ Momma n them “ is near ….
Good post. Love AI subscribe by Oracle. But as a woman find number 2 on your list mildly irritating and maybe number one. Like most female positions I spend more time in the EHR than male mds do and because I’m a woman and I have to appear more empathetic than a male md, patients are willing to abuse my time where they would never do that for a very busy male doctor. Doubt me, ask your female colleagues. Keep up the good work. I would tell you to get more female MDS on sensible medicine, but there is no time – we have to go home, clean the house and do all the mental preparation for everything else.
Agree, we need more women writing here. Our submissions are overwhelmingly from men.
Cheer up ! The next generation is thinking differently! My junior partners are already decreasing their hours and dividing childcare responsibilities. My son who just finished his palliative fellowship has opted for a lower stress position to spend more time with his family.
Love it
If AI is as time saving as the EMR we’re all effed.
Yes but think of all the paper it will save!
And decrease the incidence of carpal tunnel syndrome…