12 Comments
User's avatar
John Knight, PhD's avatar

This is great advice!

1. Students can definitely tell if you are excited or into the subject you're teaching. Some of the worst classes I had as a student were with teachers who clearly hated the class. One even walked in and complained for five minutes that he needed to teach it.

2. Don't be a hider!

3. One thing that I could never understand about some professors I've worked with in the past is how they either dreaded or had disdain for questions. I once worked with a professor who had been teaching for 20 years, and she was still scared to death of student questions.

4. I would also add: "I didn't have time to...."

5. Finishing on time is important. Being aware of the time is, too! This applies to exams, too.

Expand full comment
Harrison's avatar

Humor is king!

I’m Harrison, an ex fine dining industry line cook. My stack "The Secret Ingredient" adapts hit restaurant recipes (mostly NYC and L.A.) for easy home cooking.

check us out:

https://thesecretingredient.substack.com

Expand full comment
Benjamin Hourani's avatar

Great points.

Having given many talks over 40 years, there’s one thing that has always helped capture on audience.

I always began with a joke that I customized for the audience. A group guffaw set the stage for enjoyment and heightened expectation for whatever is to come.

In this vien: “how much were you guys paid to come to this talk”

Ben Hourani

Expand full comment
Isaac G Leon-Acuna's avatar

Loved reading this post so much. Thank you! 🙏

Expand full comment
One After 909's avatar

One in many posts that tell me my money is well spent on this Substack. I printed it up and will refer to it the next time I give a talk.

Way back in The Pleistocene, a Biochemistry professor at MSU gave a 45 minute lecture about DNA weaving in his personal experiences working Watson’s and Crick’s lab while explaining nucleotide synthesis, molecular structure, bonding points, and helical arrangement. He’d throw in anecdotes about one of them in the lab, in a Pub, or in a lecture, all relevant to the immediate point. Animated and enthusiastic, he was hilarious at times but at no time did I not feel like it was a serious lecture. When he was finished I knew DNA. At its conclusion, the scene was out of the film The Paper Chase we stood up and applauded.

As they say I wish I had it on tape.

When I’m giving a talk I think about that lecture.

P.S. If you haven’t seen The Paper Chase, it’s well worth a viewing.

Expand full comment
Adam Cifu, MD's avatar

I also wish you had that on tape!!!!

Expand full comment
Abdulmalik Koya, MD's avatar

Succinct summary. ‘Teaching’ is something I am very passionate about but not very skillful at doing. I believe for some, especially during the early career, being nervous affects the presentation??

Expand full comment
RoseyT's avatar

A lecture is a performance. While it may not be theatre, many of the same rules apply.

Expand full comment
LHS's avatar

Love this one from Dr. Friedmann. "Act out of the conviction that your teaching matters, even though you may not be able to prove this."

Expand full comment
Adam Cifu, MD's avatar

What?!?? But that argues against evidence based medicine. 😂

Expand full comment
Mary Braun Bates, MD's avatar

I especially appreciate the advice about questions from the audience. The advice about striking a balance between one with questions and everyone else. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Gene's avatar

Love this article. Excellent points.

Expand full comment