24 Comments
User's avatar
Bernie Black's avatar

For the Al-Aly and coauthors studies of recent boosters (in NEJM and JAMA IM), I wrote letters to the editor saying that the results were deeply affected by healthy vaccinee bias, and explaining why. Both were rejected by the editors. Write to me and ask for them if you want to see them (bblack@northwestern.edu). Or maybe Sensible Medicine will want to pick them up.

Bernie Black, Northwestern University

Edward's avatar

How is it that this Rind character can possibly rely on NEJM agitprop article?! This is jaw-dropping! Middle school algebra

Student would know better. And then to assert it as unassailable truth! And to claim “data” generated? These people are clueless on basic math

David J Friedman MD PC's avatar

Dr. Rind is also misrepresenting the definition of immunologically naive when stating that population is no longer immunologically naive in 2026. Many people had some form of pre-existing immunity to former corona viral exposures back in 2020. The immune system develops flexible cross-reactive responses that are immeasurable by just IgG titers. Studying tissue resident memory cells (cytobrushes of sinus mucosa) and plasma cell activation to viral like particles may better define those with mucosal protection rather than just measuring IgG titers. MD Anderson published a study in mRNA SARS-COV2 vaccine recipients with melanoma. Some recipients had interferon raised 280-fold. Not randomized study showing benefits in melanoma. Raising interferon in a healthy person that much may cause tissue damage even in 3rd trimester in pregnant women. Giving non-specific mRNA vaccines to cancer patients may have favorable risk/benefit ratios if better human clinical studies confirm it. I wish we could better utilize interferons for viral and cancer protection.

Ernest N. Curtis's avatar

The statement that the mRNA shots saved a lot of lives is not true. The study from NEJM that is cited doesn't appear to have anything to do with mortality. Claims of efficacy based on symptoms and serologic response have, in my opinion, no scientific validity.

April's avatar

I appreciate SM for this and am glad that Dr. Rind wrote about his piece. However, I am biased and align with Vinay. At our academic center, there was an increase in miscarriages, still births, and other issues in L&D by the fall of 2021 into and thru 2022. In 2026, everyone has been exposed/has had COVID. With all the known and unknowns still out there with the mRNA technology, it makes no sense to give the shot in pregnancy. I would like to know where the data pointing to women in pregnancy having a more severe reaction with COVID than women who are not pregnant.

Larry J Miller MD's avatar

Vaccinations and COVID

It is incredible that physicians can still believe that COVID vaccinations have a net benefit over the harm they caused.

In Haiti, where I served as a missionary several times, the death rate from COVID as of December 2024 was 75 per million. Only 3 percent of the population was vaccinated, and they did not wear masks at all, they did not close schools, they did not social distance and they gathered in huge crowds. I verified this with Dr. Pepe, the chief of infectious diseases in Haiti, a friend of mine.

In the USA the death rate from COVID as of 2024 was 3,100 per million. And 85 percent of the population was vaccinated. People wore masks, social distanced, stayed inside and schools were closed.

You are smart people. Please tell me the reason why America had more COVID deaths than any other country in the world. And why Haiti did so well without vaccinations. I know. Do you?

Steve Cheung's avatar

On the one hand, VP’s standard of demanding causal evidence via RCT is tried and true, and unimpeachable.

OTOH, we learned early in med school to never say never (or always).

And on the third hand, little of what is done for (and used in) pregnant women would ever meet any rigorous evidence standard (cuz hardly any of it has been subjected to RCT).

Of course, ACOG goes too far, as does just about every guideline committee on just about every clinical topic in 2026. They can and should be ignored.

But if I was caring for a pregnant woman, I’d have them read this to help them make an informed decision.

Dr. K's avatar

Rind is placing himself solidly in the data-free/evidence-free/I'll-make-something-plausible-up doctor category of such luminaries as Ezekiel Emanuel and Eric Topol. Shame for those two to have more company, but there you go. Thanks, Vinay, for being far more correct.

NeverDull's avatar

Very interesting counterpoint, but I find Dr. Prasad's argument far more persuasive. Pregnant women are a uniquely vulnerable population and caution must remain the first rule.

Jim Ryser's avatar

Thinking clearer bc of Sensible Medicine! My first thoughts are always “where are the RCT’s?” As I look back and try to untangle the politics and media/propaganda sensationalism (I admit I watched the CNN banners a few times), and ultimately the fear - I look back and see how fear was quite prevalent with me. I’ve always been a staunch reductionist as much as possible with pharmaceuticals. Especially the past 20/30 years. So being a fan of doing as little harm as possible for myself and others always takes precedence. I always focus on a spiritual aspect (I know, BAAAAD news for some) but every decision I have collaborated with my caregivers has gotten me to 62 years old with a most incredible life behind and present and ahead. The fact that this writer should be dead multiple times over lends credence (but not via an RCT! 😜) to a belief that ya, there is a higher power and neither I nor science is it.

Bon Kwi Kwi's avatar

Rind’s first asserted “truth” is based on the flawed NEJM article where the cheap trick of delaying Covid case counts until two weeks after the second vaccination was employed to skew the data (method debunked by Neil Fenton in “Where Are The Numbers”).

https://wherearethenumbers.substack.com/p/vaccine-efficacy-cheap-trick-by-exclusion?r=mzsbg&utm_medium=ios

So he’s right, there was no need to read the rest of his machinations.

David J Friedman MD PC's avatar

Why do several countries report increased excessive mortality data in 2021 compared to 2020? More people died in many countries in 2021 with vaccines on the market and almost 70% taking at least one mRNA vaccine in developed countries. New Zealand's data very scary!! Pfizer just saw decent harm in their elderly mRNA influenza vaccine not published in their NEJM 11/25 article where they only publish the mRNA results from ages 18-64. Vaccine harms are under-reported and positive effects are over-hyped. Like vaccines may prevent dementia?? I am confident that muscles or myocytes are not the proper target of immunization for mucosal pathogens. I know that the status quo prevents better, safer vaccines like "dead" core structural proteins delivered into the mucus membranes or tonsils for that matter!! In 10-25 influenza vaccine was "rubbed" into the skin of mice and produced better immunogenecity than IM injection. Lets use an immune organ like skin (cutaneous) or MALT to educate immunity for protection. I decline IM vaccines as they do not communicate well with my mucus membranes and portals of pathogen entry!! Would love for you guys to highlight how cutaneous and mucus membrane vaccine are likely superior to IM route!!

Michael Plunkett's avatar

East coast versus west coast. The former are generally hide bound, the latter more inquisitive and prone to prefer evidence to the ways things have always been done. How ab out another question? How many countries in the world are still recommending Covid vaccine for pregnant women? How many are recommending Covid shots for children? I have a feeling this is an example of American exceptionalism.

Larry J Miller MD's avatar

This is proof that medicine in the USA is controlled by Big Pharma.

Julia's avatar

Thank you so much to both contributors. Appreciate everybody’s time.

Donna's avatar

And Vinay for win 🏁